Submission to the Universal Periodic Review of the People’s Republic of China

In June 2023, China Labor Watch submitted a Universal Periodic Review of the People’s Republic of China to the United Nations in the 45th Session of the UN Universal Periodic Review cycle. This submission highlights China Labor Watch’s concerns regarding human trafficking, violations of labor rights, migrant workers’ rights, the right to freedom of expression, and the right to freedom of movement.

Introduction

1. China Labor Watch (CLW) submits the following information regarding China’s implementation of the recommendations of its third cycle Universal Periodic Review (UPR). This report will focus on human trafficking, violations of labor rights, migrant workers’ rights, the right to freedom of expression, and the right to freedom of movement according to a) The Charter of the United Nations; b) The Universal Declaration of Human Rights; c) Human rights instruments to which a State is party; d) Voluntary pledges and commitments made by States, including those undertaken when presenting their candidatures for election to the Human Rights Council; and e) Applicable international humanitarian law.

2. In addition to its national laws, China has human rights obligations as a result of the ratification of the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights (ICCPR), International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights (CESCR), the United Nations Convention against Transnational Organized Crime (UNTOC) – with a supplemental protocol the Protocol to Prevent, Suppress and Punish Trafficking in Persons, Especially Women and Children, and the Forced Labor Convention. However, the Trafficking Protocol does not apply to Hong Kong. 

3. The Chinese criminal code criminalized some forms of sex trafficking and labor trafficking. Labor trafficking offenses could be prosecuted under Article 244, which criminalized forcing a person “to work by violence, threat, or restriction of personal freedom” and recruiting, transporting, or otherwise assisting in forcing others to labor, and prescribed three to 10 years’ imprisonment and a fine. However, implementation of anti-trafficking legislation remains weak, while measurements, monitoring, and reporting on trafficking within China is lacking.

4. In the third UPR cycle, China vowed commitment to strengthen and develop legislation that promotes the protection of labor and social rights, and to improve laws and regulations regarding the rights and interests of workers and labor unions. However, since the last cycle, there is a lack of evidence that China has put forth a strong legislative effort to strengthen the protection of labor rights.

5. In the third UPR cycle, China refused to ratify the International Labour Organization (ILO) Forced Labour Convention, 1930 (No. 29) and its 2014 Protocol. In 2022, China ratified the Forced Labour Convention, 1930 (No. 29) and the Abolition of Forced Labour Convention, 1957 (No. 105). With these ratifications, China’s implementation and commitment to respect, promote and realize the ILO Fundamental Principles and Rights at Work are to be observed.

6. CLW commends China’s normative frameworks that have been developed through, inter alia, Chinese Constitution, the 1995 Labor Law of the People’s Republic of China; the 2008 Labor Contract Law of the People’s Republic of China; the  Law of the People’s Republic of China on Labor Dispute Mediation; and Arbitration Labor Union Law of the People’s Republic of China; Law of the People’s Republic of China on Work Safety; and the Social Security Law. However, more efforts need to be made to fully implement these legal frameworks.

Forced Labor and Labor Trafficking

7. Despite troubling reports in the recent decade published by various news and civil society sources, China’s existing legal framework offers ambiguous explanations for the trafficking of persons, especially for labor trafficking and forced labor. Some courts likely continued to prosecute trafficking crimes under laws pertaining to domestic violence, labor contract violations, and child abuse, all of which prescribed lesser penalties.

8. According to the Protocol to Prevent, Suppress and Punish Trafficking in Persons Especially Women and Children, China has the obligation to protect the privacy and identity of victims of trafficking in persons, ensure that its domestic legal or administrative system contains measures that provide to victims of trafficking in persons, consider implementing measures to provide for the physical, psychological and social recovery of victims of trafficking in persons, establish comprehensive policies, programmes and other measures to prevent and combat trafficking in persons and to protect victims of trafficking in persons from revictimization. China has obligations to prohibit private individuals, companies or associations from hiring individuals through the use of coercion, abduction, fraud or deception.

9. Migrant workers vulnerable to forced labor are also vulnerable to human trafficking. Based on the International Labor Organization’s indicators of trafficking of adults for labor exploitation, CLW has found strong indicators of human trafficking of Chinese migrant workers within Chinese-run companies operating in countries across Asia, Africa, South Asia, and Europe in all six dimensions of labor trafficking: deceptive recruitment, coercive recruitment, recruitment by abuse of vulnerability, exploitation, coercion at destination, and abuse of vulnerability at destination. CLW found that workers have been deceived about legal documentation, travel and recruitment conditions, which make them victims of deceptive recruitment of labor trafficking. However, the Chinese government has often turned a blind eye to this, despite many workers reported concerted effort to contact local Chinese law enforcement and Chinese embassies in these countries, often with no to little response. Many Chinese employers are also blatantly violating their legal obligation to follow due immigration procedures and all legal requirements before hiring Chinese workers. Illegally employed because of the lack of valid work visas, nonsignature of labor contract or entrance of employment relationship under exploitative terms, or contracted through a third party subcontractor that exploits workers rights, among other issues, some workers found little means to protect their legal rights.

10. The COVID-19 pandemic further exacerbated labor rights abuses against Chinese workers in foreign countries. Because of China’s restrictive pandemic policies, international flights to China were extremely limited until the officials lifted COVID restrictions in December, 2022. This, coupled with the restrictive quarantine and testing requirements imposed upon international travelers, further restricted Chinese workers’ freedom of movement aside from the existing restriction imposed through the often employed confiscation of identity documents, close-loop management, and wage manipulation tactics employed by the employers.

11. Chinese officials appear to identify their activities against sex trafficking of women and children as the corpus of its anti-trafficking effort and do little to identify and assist victims of forced labor within or outside of the country. According to CLW’s engagement with workers, there is also a concerning pattern that workers were left to fend for their own–not only without the active support from their government, but often had to collect their own evidence to prove their victimized experiences when they decided to raise the case to the Chinese court. A further concern is that the officials exhibit a pattern in penalizing victims of labor trafficking engaged in unlawful acts traffickers compelled them to commit in Southeastern countries such as Laos, Myanmar, and Cambodia. Through interviewing, CLW found that some Chinese victims of labor trafficking in cyber-crime syndicates were fearful of both their traffickers and the authorities. 

12. Based on the International Labor Organization’s indicators of trafficking of adults for labor exploitation, CLW has also found strong indicators of human trafficking of migrant workers within China in all six dimensions of labor trafficking: deceptive recruitment, coercive recruitment, recruitment by abuse of vulnerability, exploitation, coercion at destination, and abuse of vulnerability at destination. As JS4 noted in the third cycle, migrant workers’ status as “second class citizens” persists.

Labor Rights

13. According to the ICESCR and national law, workers in China have the right to: the opportunity to earn a living through work which can be freely chosen or accepted, remuneration including for public holidays, safe and healthy working conditions, equal opportunity, and rest, leisure and reasonable limitations of working hours. Workers also have the right to form and join the trade union of their choice and to take part in meetings and activities of trade unions and of any other associations established in accordance with law. According to the national law, workers have yet to gain the rights to strike or to assemble, rights that are stipulated in international law.

14. Chinese law violates international worker rights standards above, because the Party-led ACFTU is the only legally recognized trade union organization, and Chinese workers are prohibited from creating or joining independent trade unions. Collective bargaining, moreover, is absent from the Chinese Labor Law. 

15. Through direct correspondence with over Chinese worker who worked or are working in overseas BRI projects in Algeria, Serbia, Indonesia, and Democratic Republic of the Congo from 2021 to today, CLW found the following list of issues: Misleading or outright deceptive job ads, pre-work deposits, and harsh appraisal systems, all of which place workers in a fundamentally disadvantaged position; Restriction of personal freedom through the arbitrary use of fines, the withholding of identification documents, the accumulation of wage arrears, and, again, the exaction of pre-work deposits; Threats and use of physical violence to prevent workers from running away, resisting management, or contacting the media or local authorities; Either enforced signing of  contracts without workers’ expressed understanding of their terms, or, in some cases, the absence of any contract whatsoever; Workers’ unfamiliarity with their host societies and ignorance of the avenues of legal recourse that might be available to them; Strict COVID-19 policies that limit workers’ ability to pursue job options in China; Complicity of various parties, including the local police, hired Chinese ex-military guards, and, occasionally, Chinese embassies and consulates that took part in surveilling and controlling workers.

16. As a case example, one Chinese worker at Bindan, Riau island worksite told CLW that he was hit by a 66 pound falling tarpaulin when he was preparing construction tools. He experienced severe leg fractures and high fever, but the manager refused to pay any medical fees after surgery, instead pushing his colleagues to co-pay his fees. He told CLW that his legs were infected and gangrenous due to the poor medical conditions. He did not receive any medical compensation or even wages during leave for his work injury from the company. At the Virtue Dragon Nickel Industry (VDNI, or Delong) worksite in Kendari, Sulawesi, some workers with severe or mild work injuries reported that they did not receive any medical compensation from their employer. Instead, the workers themselves were forced to pay for medical care for injuries received in the course of their employment and did not receive any pay while on sick leave. Poor working conditions have also instigated a worker strike among Indonesian workers, which later escalated into a conflict. Two workers, one Indonesian and one Chinese, died during the incident. 

17. While workers have the legal right to unionize and participate in bargaining, Chinese workers in China and countries noted above, to different degrees, are routinely denied their fundamental right to strike and to both form and join unions of their choice and take part in relevant activities. The latter is a blatant violation of the Chinese Labor Law. Without any real protections for these rights, workers can only react passively to exploitations such as the unequal payment of wages, wage arrears delayed by almost three months or even six months in some cases, unsafe working conditions, unreasonable overtime hours, and no holiday or sick pay. Many workers in correspondence with CLW reported a lack of knowledge in their fundamental rights to strike and to assembly.

Freedom of Expression

18. According to the ICCPR, ICRMW, and national law, migrant workers shall have the right to hold opinions without interference, including the right to freedom of expression (freedom to seek, receive and impart information and ideas of all kinds, regardless of frontiers, either orally, in writing or in print, in the form of art, or through any other media of his choice). The national law provides for the freedom of expression in the forms of association and assembly, the right to express his opinion in public, including the right to strike, freedom of delivering opinion in public, and the right to freedom of information. 

19. A violation of workers’ right to a safe working environment and the right to freedom of expression is occurring to Chinese migrant workers according to our investigations. As a case example, a worker informed CLW that in several Chinese steel companies’ industrial parks in Indonesia, after the outbreak of the Covid-19 pandemic, the only measures to protect the health and safety of workers was to isolate workers with fevers and to block any news spreading online. The companies also encouraged employees to turn in anyone who spoke out online. Workers were afraid to send messages about the actual number of coronavirus infections in the WeChat group, because their phone would be confiscated and locked up if they were caught. CLW also received a document from an informant, issued by an industrial park in Indonesia. According to the document, the management of the industrial park fined a certain company over $10,000 for its employees’ actions “spreading negative information” about the industrial park. The statement also alerted companies in the park to better manage workers’ actions. This practice could be more common among Chinese companies in- and outside China, despite CLW has only been able to find anecdotal evidence for this.

Recommendations

  • Sign and ratify the following: the ILO C97 Migration for Employment Convention, ILO C143 Migrant Workers Convention, the United Nations International Convention on the Protection of the Rights of All Migrant Workers and Members of their Families, and the United Nations Convention against Transnational Organized Crime (UNTOC).
  • Fully implement the following: UNTOC; the Protocol to Prevent, Suppress, and Punish Trafficking; Anti-Trafficking Law No. 21/2007.
  • Incorporate the language of international anti-forced labor treaties into its domestic labor laws and legislations and implement systematic measures to hold the agencies accountable for acts such as deceptive recruiting, confiscation of passports, and illegal contracting practices. 
  • Fully implement the 1994 Labor Law, and establish accountability mechanisms within China’s government bureaucracy to monitor the implementation of said law.
  • Fully implement and establish accountability mechanisms for domestic laws governing overseas employment of Chinese workers, including: the Administrative Regulation on Contracting Foreign Projects (对外承包工程管理条例),  Regulations on the Management of Foreign Labor Service Cooperation (对外劳务合作管理条例), and the Provisions on the Administration of Intermediary Activities for Overseas Employment (境外就业中介管理规定). Ensure migrant and foreign workers enjoyment of labor rights, including humane standards of living and working conditions, freedom of expression, and freedom of movement; Mediate conflicts between local and migrant workers through official agencies and legal assistance.
  • The Chinese legislative authorities should take steps to consolidate the legislations above, and, in it, use clear language to assign or establish new monitoring bodies to ensure the implementation of said legislation targeting overseas employment. The legislation should add stronger language on labor protection, or clearly and unequivocally establish that workers of Chinese citizenship–regardless of their work locations–as jurisdiction under the China Labor Law, or other relevant legislation.
  • Abolish the practice of requiring the litigants/victims/complainants/plaintiffs of labor disputes to provide evidence to support their cases within the Chinese justice system. The burden of proof, instead, should be placed on the employers in court to protect workers’ rights. 
  • The main monitoring body for laws governing overseas employment above, the Chinese Ministry of Commerce and its municipalities should fully implement relevant legislations and perform their official duties to regulate overseas entities’ behavior.
  • Relevant state agencies should routinely monitor worksites to inspect for victims of human trafficking, conduct targeted investigations into local workplaces that are suspected of perpetuating physical violence and rights abuses against migrant workers. 
  • Establish mechanisms such as an anti-trafficking task force within the government bureaucracy to better engage with the issue of forced labor and labor trafficking. 
  • Before workers travel abroad, immigration and customs authorities should ensure that passports are held by migrant workers’ themselves during their work period and fine employers who illegally confiscate workers’ ID; Prohibit and take action against Chinese companies who apply for illegal visas such as business and travel visas for migrant workers and increase immigration authorities’ education and awareness of human trafficking to reduce the criminalization of trafficked workers without legal visas.
  • Take legal action against companies and offenders who violate these provisions and provide support for victims and survivors who were trafficked to foreign countries. This should coordinate with state parties to provide repatriation to survivors and free and affordable short-term shelter and services.
  • Increase the transparency of government efforts to combat trafficking and provide disaggregated data on investigations and prosecutions, victim identification, and service provision, including by continuing to share relevant data with international partners. 
  • Authorities should implement a third-party monitoring mechanism to examine, control, and monitor labor rights abuse.