Disney

The Dark Side of the Glittering World: A Report on Exploitation in Toy Factories in China

Download the Report Executive Summary 1) Context: the Left-Behinds of the Chinese Economic Miracle From the late 1970’s, China’s economy has enjoyed 30 years of explosive growth. With its 1.4 billion inhabitants, it is now the world’s largest economy. This economic miracle, now on everyone’s lips, has lifted hundreds of millions of Chinese out of poverty and made China a key player in globalization. A middle class, consuming goods and services, and confident in its potential for enrichment has emerged. But…

Read MoreThe Dark Side of the Glittering World: A Report on Exploitation in Toy Factories in China

A Nightmare for Workers: Appalling Conditions in Toy Factories Persist

Download the report Executive Summary To this day, most toys are made in China. They are the source of children’s dreams all over the world. However the process through which these dreams are created remains a nightmare. Countless hours of overtime, contact with dangerous chemicals and poor wages barely enough to live on are some of the biggest problems. This report reveals violations found in four factories that produce, among others, for the biggest toy brands Hasbro, Disney, and Mattel…

Read MoreA Nightmare for Workers: Appalling Conditions in Toy Factories Persist

Follow-up Investigative Report on Early Light

Download the report Executive Summary  Toys play a starring role in many a childhood memory. Take a walk through a playground on a summer day and chances are you will see children running around, chasing each other with Nerf guns or playing make believe with Disney princess dolls. As innocent and idyllic as the playground scene may seem to be, the process of how those toys make it into our children’s hands is much less picturesque.Early Light International Ltd. Co. is…

Read MoreFollow-up Investigative Report on Early Light

The Dark Side of the Toy World

Download the report Press Release On August 11, 2017, China Labor Watch dispatched investigators to four toy factories in China, including Shaoguan Early Light, Dongguan Changan Mattel, Dongguan Qualidux (Guangda), Shenzhen Winson (Taiqiang). These factories primarily supply for Walmart, Disney, Mattel, Hasbro, Target, Big Lots, Costco, Bandai, Infantino, Zoli, Combi, TOMY, Hama, Lanvin, and other companies. Many of these brand companies have promised to uphold the rights of factory workers, establishing codes of conduct. Yet our findings suggest that they…

Read MoreThe Dark Side of the Toy World

An Investigation into Four Toy Sweatshops

Download the report The world of toys is a heaven for children, but may be a world of misery for toy factory workers. Workers have to be apart from their loved ones: children, parents and their better half. They put in 11 hours every day, and work 6 or 7 days a week, but earn only the minimum wage standard as stipulated by law in harmful and toxic working environments. 10 workers are squeezed into a small dormitory room, and…

Read MoreAn Investigation into Four Toy Sweatshops

The Dark World of Disney

Download the report Li Qiang’s Open Letter Disney’s fairytales are all stories of heroes who defeat the wicked, with a prince saving the princess, and good triumphing over evil. However, these are all beautiful fairytale stories, but the truth behind the manufacture of Disney’s toys is far different. The manufacturing process of Disney toys in China, is a process of oppressing Chinese workers. At the Zhen Yang Toy factory in Dongguan, Guangdong province, where Frozen products are manufactured, many thousands…

Read MoreThe Dark World of Disney

The Other Side of Fairy Tales: An investigation of labor conditions at five Chinese toy factories

Download the report Executive Summary The joyful fairy tales associated with many toys are belied by the tragic stories woven into toy production. In workshops that are hazardous to their health, millions of workers toil under cruel management, 11 hours a day, six days per week. Over the course of a year, a toy worker may only be able to see her parents and children one time. Making the minimum wage, workers must bear such conditions just to get by. Many…

Read MoreThe Other Side of Fairy Tales: An investigation of labor conditions at five Chinese toy factories

Barbie, Mickey Mouse, Optimus Prime, Thomas the Tank Engine: Who Else Continues to Exploit Toy Workers?

Download the report Executive Summary China is the largest manufacturer of toys in the world, and Guangdong Province is the top toy manufacturing region within China. In 2007, China Labor Watch (CLW) conducted an in-depth investigation of toy factories in Guangdong that supplied to major international toy brand companies. The investigation revealed labor rights violations that included mandatory overtime, wages below the legal minimum, unpaid overtime wages, unpaid insurance, harsh and high-pressure working conditions, poor living conditions, and abusive management.…

Read MoreBarbie, Mickey Mouse, Optimus Prime, Thomas the Tank Engine: Who Else Continues to Exploit Toy Workers?

Deterioration of Mattel’s Labor Conditions: An Investigation of Four Factories

目录 I. 美泰劳工环境恶化:对四家供应工厂的调查 1. 简介 2. 空头承诺:美泰的企业社会责任 3. 中国劳工观察最新调查和美泰对劳工权益的侵犯 4. 改变迫在眉睫 美泰劳工环境恶化:对四家供应工厂的调查 1.简介 当公众注意力都聚集在苹果、富士康和电子产业中的血汗工厂时,玩具产业正面临着劳工环境恶化、产业工人的合法权益受侵犯的局面。。 作为世界上最大的玩具公司,美泰在2011年的营业额达到63亿美元,其中利润高达7.68亿美元。鉴于其如此高的利润,似乎我们可以认为像美泰这样的大公司会善待为其生产玩具的工人们。但是不幸的是事实并非如此。本报告将证明美泰的企业社会责任(Corporate Social Responsibility, CSR) 只是空头承诺。 本报告由四个部分组成。首先,我们要探讨一下美泰的企业社会责任概况。其次,我们将介绍中国劳工观察基于10月和11月对生产美泰产品的四家工厂的调查而完成的最新调查报告的主要调查结果。第三,我们提出美泰应该采取的措施以改正这些工厂里的侵权行为。最后,我们附上每家工厂的调查报告。 2.空头承诺:美泰的企业社会责任 美泰公司在15年前是最早建立“全球制造准则”(Global Manufacturing Principles)的品牌之一。至2012年,美泰连续五年入榜财富杂志的“百强最想为其工作的企业”(”100 Best Companies to Work For” ),并多年被企业责任杂志评为“百强企业公民”(”100 Best Corporate Citizens”)[1]。 此番荣誉似乎展示着美泰作为企业社会责任的领跑者,且美泰也在塑造这样的一个印象。但细看美泰从2009到2011的年报,我们发现每年都超过120多页的年报全无CSR的任何内容。在其网站或全球公民报告中美泰也全然未提其供应工厂CSR合规的信息。这方面的空白是美泰CSR概况的一贯特色。 在其网站上的企业责任部分,美泰作出承诺,对于海外的直属工厂及代工厂每年都执行不定期的审计,同时也与ICTI的ICTI CARE Process (ICP)合作进行年度审计。任何有雇佣童工、强迫劳动或人口交易的行为美泰都将实行“零容忍”政策[2];对于工厂的其他违法违规行为也将责令工厂进行整改措施。 可惜的是,这样的行动计划似乎只是虚有其表,并无实际意义。就在同一部分中,美泰发布了2009年至2011年的ICP审计结果。这些审计报告的格式和结果应当引起我们的关注。 美泰在海外共有七家直属工厂,其中中国内地有4家。每家工厂的独立审计报告(包括整改措施)仅有两页。而2011年ICP年报的仅是一张简单的表格,半页的篇幅在总结所有7家工厂的状况。只有一家工厂的工时记录系统不合格,其他工厂都获得了ICP的合规认证。 但是实际问题远比独立报告中指出的工时记录不合格严重的多。诚然,审计发现中国工厂的工人加班时间(80到120小时)远超中国法定标准。事实上,这同时也同美泰自己备受尊崇的全球制造准则相悖。该准则第2a条称:“工作时间必须符合国家和美泰的要求”。 尽管所有中国工厂存在工作时长方面的非法性和矛盾,所有工厂仍然被授予合格证书。仅有一份审计报告在“改正行为”一栏提及了工作时长。即使这样,该行为也是无意义的:因为美泰的计划是“寻求确保”工作时长的合法性。 美泰于2009年开始使用ICP。此前,美泰的审计是由一家叫做Sethi International Center for Corporate Accountability (SICCA)的非盈利组织进行的。从SICCA的主页上,我们可以看到其在2008年对美泰直属工厂和供应工厂的详细审计报告,分别长达30和40页。每份报告详细的描述了工厂状况,依据主题细分各部分,比如招聘、记录、安全等。 更重要的是,SICCA提及了大部分美泰工厂都普遍存在的许多具体问题。问题数量之多,令SICCA在其供应工厂报告的结论中无奈的说:“SICCA对其审计的完整性以及审计结果不满意。”在这些工厂进行了三年审计后,SICCA没有看到显著改进: “在三年中进行了三次正式审计后,而正常的安排应该是每三年一次正式审计,SICCA感到其提出的任何关于改善行动的建议都不会实现有意义的改变,除非美泰承诺工厂必须实行这些建议。” 值得注意的是从2001到2008的八年来,SICCA在其每份报告中均指出超量加班的情况。然而,这种情况并未得到改善。 美泰反而在2009年加入了ICTI CARE Process,随之美泰的企业社会责任系统开始倒退。ICP 审计报告篇幅短、无具体内容且仅仅检视美泰七家直属工厂的状况。从2008年开始,美泰就从未发布关于其供应工厂的劳工状况,尽管美泰在其2012年全球公民报告中承诺分享关于“我们主要供应商的总体表现”的信息。 美泰的CSR在过去的十年中逐步解体。美泰曾经让SICCA对数十家直属和供应工厂进行全面审计并提供详细的报告,而现在却只发布ICP完成的表面化的覆盖七家工厂的两页报告。 美泰同SICCA似乎不欢而散。当SICCA觉得它的建议“不会实现有意义的改变”,也许它就不再愿意继续为美泰进行审计了。抑或美泰觉得SICCA对美泰道义的要求过于严格。从这个意义上,美泰可能会觉得ICTI是更合适的伙伴。 不管美泰CSR系统的恶化是出于什么原因,很明显,美泰的承诺现在是空洞而无意义的。我们不得不提出这样的疑问:美泰到底是否是真心想信守其“保证我们的玩具的生产过程是负责任的”的承诺。 3.中国劳工观察最新调查和美泰对劳工权益的侵犯 以下介绍中国劳工观察对位于广东省的四家生产美泰产品的工厂的调查结果。其中一家工厂是由美泰直接控制的。调查于2012年10月和11月间进行。这些工厂分别为佛山市南海美泰精密压铸有限公司(“南海美泰”)、郭氏宏高电子塑胶(深圳)有限公司(“郭氏宏高”)、东莞东耀玩具有限公司(“东耀”)、深圳市伟利丰塑胶制品有限公司(“伟利丰”)。它们一共聘用了大约一万名工人。 南海美泰是其中唯一一家由美泰直接控制的工厂,且其只生产美泰的产品。其他工厂在生产美泰产品以外,还向其他公司提供玩具,比如迪斯尼、麦当劳和孩之宝。 除伟利丰之外,调查员佯装工人进入工厂数天或数周,以实地取得工人待遇的第一手资料。由于伟利丰当时并未招聘工人,我们的调查员就通过在工厂外和多名工人交谈而获取劳工情况。 虽然四家工厂都从美泰的审计员那里获得了“合规证书”,所有工厂都存在着法律或道义上的对劳工权益的侵犯。中国劳工观察的调查发现至少15项侵权行为: 1. 加班工资不合法。在郭氏宏高,正式工的工作日加班工资只有10元œ«17元/小时。此项侵权影响重大:这家工厂应欠工人数千万元的工资。 2. 超量加班。所有四家工厂的每月加班数量都是法定36小时的数倍。许多工人每两周才能休息一天。最差的是东耀。在旺季,工人得加180到210小时的班。此外,为了使工人在周日加班,东耀不记录工人的工时,而是就工人周日的工作支付现金,但是支付的金额远低于法定加班工资。中国劳工观察要求工厂必须记录工人的工时。 3. 强制劳动。在南海美泰,工厂规章要求加班必须是自愿的。但是在现实中,工人工作8小时后下班的请求管理人员从不批准。工人必须继续加班。 4. 劳动安全隐患。每家工厂在其车间内都至少有一项重大安全违规。事实上,高危岗位缺乏劳保用品是一个普遍现象。比如南海美泰和东耀的喷漆工人没有佩戴口罩,郭氏宏高和伟利丰的注塑工人没有佩戴口罩或隔音耳罩。在南海美泰,管理人员不允许调查员在喷涂玩具时佩戴手套,因为手套会降低工人的效率。看来在生产美泰玩具的工厂里,生产效率重于工人安全。 5. 缺乏劳动安全培训。我们的调查员指出南海美泰、郭氏宏高和东耀或进行仅几个小时的岗前培训敷衍了事,或干脆没有培训。虽然玩具制造是一个由于涉及化学原料而职业病高发的行业,但是安全培训在这些工厂中几乎不存在。《生产经营单位安全培训规定》第14条规定,加工、制造业等生产单位的其他从业人员,在上岗前必须经过三级安全培训教育;第15条规定生产经营单位新上岗的从业人员,岗前培训时间不得少于24学时。 6. 缺乏体检。郭氏宏高和东耀在工人入职前或入职后都没有进行体检,尽管工人健康有可能被玩具生产过程中的化学品损害。 7. 工人无法辞职。在郭氏宏高和东耀,辞职程序通常需要两个月才能完成。一些工人的辞职申请会一直被拒绝。许多工人只能自行离职,结果就是不能拿到应得的工资。依据中国劳动法,工人辞职仅需提前一个月通知雇主即可。 8. 空白合同。郭氏宏高让工人签署空白合同而不具有任何细节,如工资,雇佣日期等。 9.…

Read MoreDeterioration of Mattel’s Labor Conditions: An Investigation of Four Factories

Did Dreams Come True? Workers still live in fear of occupational injury

Workplace Injury Still Found in Chinese Supplier to Disney and Tesco A Chinese factory that supplies products to Disney and Tesco were found to have violated local labor laws due to its practices such as forcing employees to work excessive amount of overtime with a serious lack of workplace security. Employees are required to work for 13.5 hours per day during peak seasons between January and February. Employees are at the factory for at least 96 hours per week while…

Read MoreDid Dreams Come True? Workers still live in fear of occupational injury

Disney: Yiuwah Update Targets Factory, Ignores: Disney’s Exploitative System

On July 30, Disney released an update on its Yiuwah factory situation. China Labor Watch endorses Disney’s remediation plan for Yiuwah factory, and from July 30 through August 5, CLW conducted a follow-up investigation to evaluate implementation of this plan. Detailed results of the investigation are included below, and include the following lingering issues: no compensation for workers previously paid below the minimum wage, and failure to even allow workers to buy their own social insurance (only a limited number of veteran workers are allowed to…

Read MoreDisney: Yiuwah Update Targets Factory, Ignores: Disney’s Exploitative System

Shattered Dreams: Underage Worker Death at Factory Supplying to Disney, Other International Brands

Qing Ming Festival is a traditional Chinese holiday on which the living give honor to those who passed before them. For 17 year old Liu Pan, this year’s festival was no ordinary celebration of the dead: it was the last day of his life. The following day, Liu Pan’s body was to be mutilated by a paper crushing machine on which he had worked for the past two years of his young life, since he was 14 or 15. So too died…

Read MoreShattered Dreams: Underage Worker Death at Factory Supplying to Disney, Other International Brands